Relationships: Understanding Closeness, Separation, and Connection
Updated: 5 minutes ago
Often, what we defend against is the very thing we need to feel better: closeness.
Topics:
Relationships · Closeness · Communication · Self-Awareness
Who This Is For:
Men who want to understand why relationships matter so much, and what's happening inside them when a relationship that matters starts to feel distant or off.
More and more people I work with come in with relationship language they've learned from popular books or social media. You may have heard of attachment styles like secure, anxious, avoidant, or disorganized, or Gary Chapman's The 5 Love Languages: words of affirmation, quality time, receiving gifts, acts of service, and physical touch. These can be a helpful starting point. They give people words for something that can be hard to describe.
The challenge I sometimes see is that they can turn into categories people get locked into. "I'm avoidant." "My love language is physical touch and acts of service, and my partner needs to meet me there." When two people's categories don't line up, it can feel like one is speaking Mandarin and the other is speaking French. Research suggests these things are less fixed than the labels make them sound. Attachment patterns are better understood as a spectrum that can shift over time and between relationships, and a 2024 review led by Dr. Emily Impett at the University of Toronto found little support for the idea that partners need matching love languages, suggesting most people benefit from all five (University of Toronto).
I'd like to offer a more general way of understanding relationships, including, but not limited to, our intimate relationships.
Relationships are one of the places where you can feel the most hope, pressure, frustration, confusion, disappointment, sadness, desperation, and loneliness. You want closeness, understanding, ease, trust, effort, and care for the relationship. And when those things feel out of reach, it makes sense to want to understand why you feel such a strong pull to figure things out, get to the other side, and feel at rest again. Happy again.
There doesn't seem to be a place in our world where relationships don't matter. Think of the people you work with: your colleagues, your boss, your direct reports. Think of your home life: your partner or spouse, your kids, your extended family, your parents. Think of your friends, neighbours, personal trainer, doctor, even your psychologist. Some relationships are professional, some are personal, but they all share the same experience: when something in the relationship is off, we feel it.
Understanding Attachment: Why Relationships Matter So Much
Dr. Gordon Neufeld, a developmental psychologist and one of the leading voices in attachment theory, teaches that attachment is our deepest need. Much of my practice is built on his teaching, and his ideas sit underneath most of what follows.
At the start of life, attachment is survival. A baby can't feed, protect, or settle itself. It depends completely on someone else, and the instinct to stay close to that someone is built in. The need for that level of care lasts a few years. The instinct to attach lasts a lifetime.
That's why relationships can affect us so deeply, even as capable adults. When we feel connected to the people who matter, the body settles and we can rest. We think more clearly, handle stress better, and feel more like ourselves. When something feels off, the body notices, often before we've found the words for it. It also helps explain why you can feel close to some people and not others, even when you spend just as much time with both.
The Six Roots of Attachment: The Basics
Part of the reason is that connection isn't just one thing. We hold onto the people that matter to us in different ways. In the book, Hold On to Your Kids, Dr. Neufeld and Dr. Gabor Maté describe six ways of attaching, which Neufeld refers to as the six roots of attachment. In healthy development, they unfold over roughly the first six years of life, with each one deepening the one before it. They aren't rigid timelines; they unfold differently for everyone, and they stay active throughout our lives. Here are the basics:
Proximity: being physically close. Touch, presence, eye contact, being near each other.
Sameness: being alike. Shared interests, values, habits, and ways of seeing things.
Belonging and loyalty: being on the same side. Feeling part of something shared, and knowing the other person has your back.
Significance: mattering. Feeling valued and important to the other person.
Emotional intimacy (love): giving your heart. Sharing feelings and caring deeply.
Being known: being truly seen. Letting someone into your inner world, and being accepted there.
The roots show up everywhere, not just at home. Feeling like your input counts at work is significance. A friend who's always in your corner can connect with belonging and loyalty. Being honest with someone and still feeling accepted touches on being known and being seen. And when you feel close to one person but not another, it's often because different roots are in play. You might share a lot in common with a coworker, but only feel truly known by a few people in your life.
If you're a parent, the roots matter in a second way, because they're also what your kids are reaching for with you. I go into that in more depth in the Parenting and Co-Parenting article. For Neufeld's own explanation, see his talk Attachment Roots: Developing the Capacity to Hold On When Apart or Hold On to Your Kids.
The roots describe what connection is made of. The next question is what happens when that connection is interrupted, and that's where the continuum comes in.
The Relationship Continuum
Attachment, at its core, is instinctual. We're drawn toward those we're attached to, and more guarded with those we aren't. Last year I did a workshop for a Calgary company on workplace relationships, and in the process of getting the ideas out of my head and onto a PowerPoint slide, I started to see attachment more as a continuum: the movement between connection and separation in our relationships. It's a visual that has helped me understand it, and one I use to help my clients understand it too. It isn't a formal model, and it doesn't replace Dr. Neufeld's work. It's just a visual I use to help understand and explain the experience of being in relationships.
On one end is connection. On the other is separation. Much of what happens between two people happens in the movement between the two poles.

The Relationship Continuum: A slide to help understand attachment and separation in relationships.
Connection: Where We Find Rest
We start off in connection. It begins in utero, continues through infancy, and hopefully well beyond. Connection is where we feel rest: safe, settled, content, secure. Not because we need to earn it, but because the closeness is simply there.
Separation: The Part No One Avoids
No one can stay in close contact all the time; we all experience separation. A partner travels for work. A friend moves away. A boss goes quiet after a meeting. A conversation leaves two people out of sync. Separation itself is not the problem. Depending on how long it lasts, we can all handle it, as long as we restore connection.
The Alarm, and the Move to Close the Gap
When separation feels like too much, something in us sounds an alarm. That's the nervous system signalling possible danger, because at the deepest level, attachment is tied to survival. And the alarm often goes off before separation has even happened. Picture yourself coming home and telling your family, "I'm heading to Halifax on Sunday for a project," and then walking off to pack. What's the next question? "When are you coming back?" If you don't answer it, the people who love you will feel worried, alarmed, maybe frustrated. You haven't left yet. They're just facing separation, and that is enough to set off the alarm.
When the alarm goes off, the attachment instinct moves into pursuit, which is the move to close the gap and get back to connection. You might send another text, check in, ask what's wrong, work harder to be noticed, or bring something up again. That's the football player on the top line of the diagram: a natural defence against separation, driving back toward closeness. When it works, and the gap closes, you're back in tune. You can breathe again. You feel the rest you felt before.
Defensive Detachment: Guarding Against Closeness
But when there's been too much separation, when attempts to reconnect keep failing, or when closeness has been inconsistent or has come with too much hurt, the defence turns around. Instead of driving toward connection, it starts guarding against it. That's the football player on the bottom line. Neufeld describes this as defensive detachment. Writing about children, he puts it simply: "A child can bear only so much vulnerability." When closeness starts to cost too much, he describes the flight from vulnerability as "a numbing out of vulnerable feelings, a tuning out of perceptions that lead to vulnerable feelings, and even a backing out of attachment" (Neufeld Institute). Adults are no different.
Most people know this from experience. If someone you were close to ended the relationship, cheated on you, or mistreated you, you're going to be more cautious moving forward in your next dating and relationship experience. The same can happen with a friend who let you down, or a workplace that prides itself on treating employees like "family," but treats you as expendable when it counts. Being more cautious after that is normal. But if it happens again, you'll be more guarded still. The more often deep connection is followed by the pain of losing it, the harder it becomes to open up again. The depth of the connection influences how much it hurts to lose it, and it's that pain the defences are trying to avoid.
Here's what makes it so hard. What we defend against is often the very thing we need to feel better. Reaching for closeness again is risky. That risk is what being vulnerable really means, and it's exactly what the defences guard against. So some people stay detached, or only move toward the safest attachments they have. Sometimes that's a pet.
Knowing this doesn't automatically make connection easier. But it does help it make more sense, both in yourself and in the people you're trying to stay close to.
When Two People Move Differently
In any relationship that matters, both people are on the continuum at the same time. And when separation happens, they don't always move the same way.
Picture two people after a tense evening. One moves toward: they want to talk it through, check in, and make sure things are okay. The other moves away: they go quiet, need some space, and say "I'm fine." Neither one is wrong. Each is doing what their instincts tell them to do to feel safe again.
The trouble is that each move can set off the other person's alarm. The more one reaches, the more pressure the other feels, and the more they pull back. The more one pulls back, the more alarmed the other gets, and the harder they reach.
It helps to remember what's underneath. The person pulling back usually still cares. More often, they care deeply and have learned that reaching can hurt. That's why pushing harder rarely brings them closer. Closeness tends to return when it feels safe again for both people, not when it's pressured.
Where It Starts
The way you move along the continuum was likely shaped early. A young child shouldn't have to work for connection. When a parent is attuned and consistent, the closeness and connection are simply there, and the child gets to rest in it. But when that movement toward the child stops, through a parent who is often away for work, attention divided among siblings, or a parent caught up in their own struggles, such as an unhealthy marriage or mental health issues, the child adapts. The movement reverses, and the child starts pursuing the parent instead in order to satisfy their attachment needs.
That pursuit can look a lot of different ways. A child might work hard to be good, helpful, or easy to have around. They might learn to watch a parent's mood closely and adjust to it. They might keep their own feelings to themselves because there doesn't seem to be room for them. Whatever shape it takes, the child is doing the same thing: working to hold on to a closeness that used to come without effort.
This isn't about blaming parents. Many parents do the best they can with what they have, and many are carrying more than their kids ever see. But a child doesn't experience it that way. A child just knows whether closeness is there, and what it takes to keep it.
Those early experiences can shape how you move toward, or guard against, closeness as an adult. If you had to work for connection growing up, your alarm might go off sooner when someone pulls away, or you might find yourself guarding before anyone has given you a reason to. None of this is fixed. Patterns that were shaped in relationships can also be reshaped in relationships, especially ones that feel safe.
The Role of Emotions
Emotions play a big role in how attachment works. Long before we have words, our emotions are what move us toward the people we need, and what alerts us when that closeness is at risk. In Neufeld's work, emotions and attachment are closely tied together. As the Neufeld Institute puts it, "threats to togetherness constitute the essence of distress" (Neufeld Institute).
That's why some of our strongest feelings tend to show up around the people who matter most. The ease of feeling close. The worry when someone pulls away. The longing when we miss them. The frustration when we can't seem to reach them. The sadness when something we hoped for isn't going to happen. Each of these is part of the same instinct: to stay connected, or to find our way back.
I often describe emotions as navigational tools. They carry information about what's happening between us and the people we care about, and about what we might need. They don't always tell us what to do, but they do tell us that something matters.
The trouble comes when those feelings get pushed down or switched off. We can't stop ourselves from having emotions, but we can stop ourselves from feeling them by staying busy, distracting ourselves, or numbing out. That's part of what defensive detachment does. It protects us from the vulnerable feelings, but it also cuts us off from the information they carry, and from the closeness they were trying to move us toward.
How It All Fits Together
The roots, the continuum, and emotions aren’t three separate ideas. They’re three ways of looking at the same experience.
The roots describe what connection is made of, the different ways we hold on to someone, how we attach. The continuum describes the movement: from connection, into separation, and back again. And emotions are what we feel as we move, the signals that give us information about our experience of relationships.
When a relationship feels distant, people often reach for the earlier roots first, like more time together, more contact, more doing the same things, even when the real disconnection is happening at a deeper level, like significance or being known. This shows up a lot around sex.
When a relationship feels strained, some people find themselves wanting sex more, not less. In my work, this comes up often for men. Through the lens of the roots, it makes sense. Physical closeness is proximity, the first and most basic way we attach. When other kinds of connection feel out of reach, it’s natural to go back to the most basic one. Sex can feel like the one place you can still find closeness, and reassurance that you’re still wanted. And when it isn’t there, it can leave you feeling frustrated, rejected, and alone. It’s the one root you were counting on to stay connected.
Your partner may be experiencing something different. When things feel strained, they may be looking for closeness at a different root first, like feeling significant or known, or emotionally connected, before physical closeness feels right. So one person reaches for touch in order to feel close, and the other needs to feel close before touch feels good. Both are looking for the same thing. They’re just reaching for it through different roots.
Research backs up part of this. Couples therapist and clinical psychologist Sue Johnson describes “solace sex,” where sex is used mainly for reassurance that the relationship is okay, and says that “the biggest factor in the quality of your sex relationship is the safety of your emotional connection” (Sue Johnson). And in a study of 300 men, Dr. Sarah Hunter Murray found that nearly all of them said feeling desired by their partner mattered to them (PsyPost). For many men, sex is as much about connection as it is about physical release.
The roots also help explain why some relationships can handle more separation than others. The deeper the roots, the more a relationship can hold through distance and disagreement. When someone feels known and cared for by you, a busy week or a hard conversation doesn’t feel like losing you. When a connection rests mostly on being physically close, even a short separation can set off the alarm.
A More Useful Way to Think About It
Feeling unsettled when a relationship feels off doesn't mean you're needy, weak, or bad at relationships. It means your attachment instincts are doing what they were built to do. The alarm, the pull to close the gap, even the urge to guard yourself - all of it makes more sense once you see it as part of the movement between connection and separation.
Sometimes the reaction is bigger than the moment because an old root is being touched, or because closeness has cost you before. That doesn't mean something is wrong with you. It means there's a history underneath.
The goal isn't to stop needing people – because we all do – or to never feel the pull of separation. It's to understand your instincts well enough that they stop running your relationships from underneath, unseen. And to remember that often, what we defend against is the very thing we need to feel better: closeness.
What Helps
You don't need to overhaul your relationships to use this. A few habits can go a long way:
Notice the alarm. When something feels off, pause, take a breath, and ask: What am I feeling here and what is this feeling connected to? Notice what's happening in your body: tightness, restlessness, or a pull to fix, avoid, or pursue.
Get curious about the other person's alarm too. When their reaction seems bigger than the moment, ask about it. "Is this about the schedule (or whatever the presenting issue is), or is what you’re feeling connected to something else?"
Bridge the separation. Remember the Halifax example: the alarm goes off when the people who love you don't know when you're coming back. So, when you need space, answer that question before it's asked. "I need about twenty minutes, then I want to come back to this." "I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed this week; can we catch up Friday evening, after the kids are asleep?" Neufeld calls this bridging, and it puts the focus on the return to connection, rather than the separation (Neufeld Institute).
If you tend to pursue, invite rather than chase. Say what you want clearly and calmly, then give the other person time and space to move toward you. "I miss you. I'd like some time with you this weekend" is an invitation. "Why are you always so distant?" is pressure.
If you tend to guard, take small reaches. You don't have to open everything at once. Share one small, honest thing. Stay a few minutes longer than feels comfortable. It can also help to name it: "I notice I pull back when things get tense. It's not that I don't care."
Get support if the pattern keeps repeating. If the same cycle keeps coming back no matter what you try, or if anyone feels unsafe, counselling, together or on your own, can help you see the pattern more clearly.
Putting It Into Practice
Choose one or two of the questions below to explore in writing. The purpose is to notice how you move between connection and separation, and what your instincts are trying to protect.
Reflect in Writing
Think about a recent moment when a relationship that matters to you felt off or distant, whether at home, at work, or with a friend.
What did you notice in your body when it happened?
What were you feeling: alarm, longing, frustration, sadness, or numbness?
Did you move toward the other person to close the gap, or guard against closeness?
Which of the six roots feels most sensitive for you?
Growing up, was the movement toward you consistent, or did it stop at some point?
How might that show up in your relationships now?
Try This Over the Next 3 Days
Set aside five minutes at the end of each day to reflect:
Did I notice a moment of separation or disconnection today?
What was I feeling, and which way did I move?
Which root did it seem to touch?
What would bridging it, or reaching a little, have looked like?
You don't have to change everything at once. The goal is simply to notice it sooner and respond with a little more awareness each time.
Next Steps
If this is landing, you don't have to sort it out alone. Understanding your own roots is often where the real work starts, whether that's in individual sessions, in a small group with other men through The Guys, or through some of the other free resources on the site. If hard conversations are where things tend to break down, the Communication and Conflict article picks up from here.
Continue Your Growth
If this article raised something in you, consider exploring one of these next.
→ Frustration, Anger & Attack
Need More Support?
Articles can help you understand patterns.
Therapy gives you the opportunity to explore them more deeply and begin responding differently with the support of a psychologist.
.png)


Comments